I know what you're thinking - my goodness Claire that's not a very pretty looking recipe. I beg you to stay with me though because while this may not be the prettiest recipe I've ever posted, it sure is tasty and it makes up for it's lack of visual appeal with it's really-good-for-you status.
This year, I've developed a love for mushrooms, flat, button, enoki, shitake - I'll have them all. I've ordered them for breakfast, stuffed them into capsicums, eaten them with dinner, made them into a salad and even eaten mushroom ice-cream.
Ever since I found out just how good for you they are, I've been hooked. The last couple of weeks I've even been having mushroom and feta omelets for lunch.
My latest challenge, as part of the Summer of Mushrooms campaign, was to come up with a Christmas-inspired mushroom recipe that could become 'the next Christmas ham for vegetarians.' Ok so I added that last big but as usual, being asked to stick to a theme and create a specific item locked up my creative juices and really had my brain working overtime.
Then, while making our December 1 Christmas ham I thought maybe I could create a cross breed between ham, turkey and mushrooms and so the Christmas stuffed mushroom was born. Despite its rather bland appearance it's packed full of flavour. The crunchy, golden crust hides a soft flavour packed center finished off with the earthy mushroom underneath.
I don't know where the idea came from but instead of using rice to stuff them, I used barley, which I later discovered is packed full of healthy things like vitamin E & B, antioxidants and fibre. Add it to the beneficial qualities of mushrooms and this is actually a pretty healthy little dish.
Just in case you've forgotten about the goodness locked in a little mushroom let me remind you. They have all the attributes of a super-food; nutrient-rich (with selenium, ergothionene, antioxidants and vitamin D), flavour-rich (their umami counterbalances saltiness so you need less salt in a mushroom dish), low in calories and their easy to buy and affordable.
I buy at least a bag of mushrooms every week from the 'mushroom man' at my local markets.
My Christmas stuffed mushrooms are really easy to make and you could make up the stuffing in advance then bake them at the last minute. They're something just a little bit different to your usual Christmas fare. I also think the stuffing would work well in little button mushrooms as a starter. I preferred the smaller ones because there was a greater ratio of crunchy topping to soft inside than the bigger ones.
I finished them off with a few cloves just like a Christmas ham and it was the icing topping on the cake mushroom. Please take note though - do not eat the cloves. Colour-wise, they tend to blend in a little once the mushrooms are cooked. I suggest using a set number on each one so you know you've removed them all.
Trust me. I accidentally ate one and it wasn't the most pleasant experience. Unless you want to know what a Christmas tree tastes like (I'm pretty sure they're clove-flavoured) be sure to remove them all!
Serve Christmas stuffed mushrooms warm with whatever condiments you like. I would suggest a mustard or chutney just like you serve with the Christmas ham. Enjoy!
What about you? Will you be cooking mushrooms this Christmas? If you're looking for some recipe ideas check out the great selection of mushroom recipes on the Power of Mushrooms website or their Facebook page.
This post was sponsored by The Australian Mushroom Growers Association as part of their Summer Of Mushrooms campaign.
Recipe

Ingredients
- 1 teaspoon olive oil
- 1 small onion diced
- 2 cloves garlic crushed
- 1 teaspoon butter
- 1 tablespoon fresh thyme leaves
- 1 teaspoon brown sugar
- 4 tablespoon bread crumbs
- 1 egg lightly beaten
- 4 button mushrooms diced finely
- ½ cup cooked barley
- salt and pepper
- 4 tea cup sized flat mushrooms
- whole cloves
Instructions
- Heat the oil in a small frying pan and saute the onions until soft.
- Add the garlic and cook for one minute and then add the butter and stir through until melted.
- Transfer to a large bowl to cool.
- Pre-heat the oven to 180C fan-forced and line a tray with baking paper.
- To the onion bowl, add everything but the field mushrooms and cloves and mix to combine.
- Divide the mixture between the mushrooms and press onto the top of each one.
- Press cloves into the mixture.
- Bake for 20-25 minutes or until crunchy and golden on top.
- Remove the cloves and serve with extra thyme and condiments of your choice
Maureen | Orgasmic Chef says
Brown food is notoriously difficult to photograph and you've done it so well! Love stuffed mushies!
Claire says
Thanks! They were rather tricky. I don't have a problem with chocolate... it looks good from any angle!
The Café Sucré Farine says
Claire, you can make anything look pretty! I think these sound amazing too, I have 5 siblings and when we were growing up we often fought over mushrooms! You'd think it would be candy or something sweet but nope, it was the mushrooms every time!
Claire says
Haha that's very cute Chris! I'd fight for them now but definitely not when I was little!
The Life of Clare says
Yum! I've never made stuffed mushrooms, even after being vegetarian for 10 years. I'm absolutely going to give these a go!
Claire says
You will most definitely have to try them then Clare. Might be too early for an egg from your chickens though!
Lorraine @ Not Quite Nigella says
I was just thinking that these would be really nice with a chutney! And hehe yes with plenty of vegos in the family, they'd love this for Christmas! :)
Claire says
Yes they'd go well in your family!
Christie @ Fig and Cherry says
Just fantastic Claire! I love the idea of serving these with chutney or mustard in lieu of ham - and I'm sorry you learnt how awful cloves taste the hard way!! ;)
Claire says
Me to Christie!